Bio-field Treatment: An Effective Strategy to Improve the Quality of Beef Extract and Meat Infusion Powder
Journal: Nutrition and Food Sciences Received June 02, 2015; Accepted June 18, 2015; Published June 23, 2015
|Nutrition and Food Sciences
Received June 02, 2015; Accepted June 18, 2015; Published June 23, 2015
|Mahendra KT, Gopal N, Shrikant P, Rama MT, Snehasis J, et al. (2015) Bio-field Treatment: An Effective Strategy to Improve the Quality of Beef Extract and Meat Infusion Powder. J Nutr Food Sci 5: 389. doi:10.4172/2155-9600.1000389|
|Bio-field Treatment: An Effective Strategy to Improve the Quality of Beef Extract and Meat Infusion Powder|
Mahendra KT, Gopal N, Shrikant P*, Rama MT, Snehasis J and Rakesh M
DOI: 10.4172/2155-9600.1000389 ISSN: 2155-9600
Mahendra KT, Gopal N, Shrikant P, Rama MT, Snehasis J, et al. (2015)Bio-field Treatment: An Effective Strategy to Improve the Quality of Beef Extract andMeat Infusion Powder. J Nutr Food Sci 5: 389. doi:10.4172/2155-9600.1000389
The present research work investigated the influence of bio-field treatment on two common flavoring agents used in food industries namely beef extract powder (BEP) and meat infusion powder (MIP). The treated powders were characterized by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), X-ray diffraction (XRD), particle size analysis, surface area analysis, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA). The FT-IR results showed disappearance of triglycerides peaks in both the treated powders as compared to control. XRD results corroborated the amorphous nature of both control and treated samples. The BEP showed enhanced average particle size (d50) and d99 (size exhibited by 99% of powder particles) by 5.7% and 16.1%, respectively as compared to control. Contrarily, the MIP showed a decreased particle size (d50;0.4% and d99; 18.1%) as compared to control.It was assumed that enormous energy was stored in MIP after bio-field treatment that led to fracture into smaller particles. The surface area was increased in both the treated powders. DSC result showed significant increase in melting temperature, in BEP and MIP, which indicated the higher thermal stability of the samples. However, the specific heat capacity (∆H) was decreased in both samples, which was probably due to high energy state of the powders.
Keywords: Beef extract powder; Meat infusion powder; Bio-field treatment; Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy; X-ray diffraction; Particle size analysis; Surface area analysis; Differential scanning calorimetry; Thermo gravimetric analysis
Abbreviations: BEP: Beef Extract Powder; MIP: Meat Infusion Powder; FT-IR: Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy; XRD: X-Ray Diffraction; DSC: Differential scanning Calorimetry; TGA: Thermo Gravimetric Analysis; CHD: Coronory Heart Disease; BET: Brunauer-Emmett-Teller; DTG: Derivative Thermo Gravimetry
Beef is known to have excellent nutritional value and it has been widely consumed in many countries. The prominent reason for this high food value is its strongest peroxide forming potential due to its excellent myoglobin and haem levels [1,2]. Beef extract powder (BEP) is highly concentrated meat stock and has been used in food industry as a flavouring agent in cooking and to prepare broth for drinks . It has been used since many years as a food additive and taste enhancer in food technological applications. On the other hand, meat infusion powder (MIP) has been used as a microbial growth medium and flavouring agent .
Coronory heart disease (CHD) is the main cause of death in western countries. The life style and genetic backgrounds are two important factors, which affects the mortality in CHD. The elevated level of triglycerides is one of the main reasons for CHD. The factors such as obesity, insulin resistance, excessive alcohol consumption, diabetes, and kidney disease also causes risk of high triglycerides . Moreover, the red meat such as beef and less dark meat chicken also have the higher triglycerides. Previously, it was suggested that removing triglycerides from cooked meat affects the aroma and thus it can affect the quality of the beef meat . Hence, reducing the triglyceride content will directly improve the health and it will improve the quality of the meat products. Currently, no alternative and cost effectiv e approaches are available to alter the content of triglycerides, but bio-field treatment may be a new approach to change the physiochemical properties of powders made from these meat products.
In physics, energy is a property of objects that can be transmitted to other objects and changed into different forms but neither can be created or destroyed . According to Einstein’s equation (E=mc2) the energy and matter are fundamentally related to each other . Nonetheless, the energy is a field of force which can significantly interact with any object at a distance and cause action. Furthermore, the energy can exists in several forms such as kinetic, potential, electrical, magnetic, and nuclear. Researchers have shown that short lived electrical events or action potential exists in several types of animal cells such as neurons, muscle cells, endocrine cells as well as plant cells. The human nervous system consist the energy/information in the form of electrical signals [9,10]. Whenever, these electrical signals fluctuate with time, the magnetic field generates as per the Ampere-Maxwell law, and cumulatively known as electromagnetic field. Hence, the electromagnetic field being generated from the human body is known as bio-field energy .
Mr. Trivedi is known to exert prominent effects on external surrounding using his unique bio-field, herein referred as Bio-field treatment. Recently, it was investigated that bio-field treatment can significantly change the characteristics of living and non-living organisms. Subjecting bio-field treatment on metals and ceramics caused significant changes in crystalline, thermal, and atomic properties [12-19]. It has been recently published that the effect of bio-field treatment resulted in significant improvement of the yield and quality of various agriculture products [20-23]. The said bio-field exposure caused an increase in growth and anatomical characteristics of an herb Pogostemon cablin that is commonly used in perfumes, in incense/insect repellents, and alternative medicine . Moreover, in microbiology, bio-field treatment has also changed the antibiotic susceptibility patterns as well as produced biochemical reactions that induced changes in the characteristics of pathogenic microbes [25-27].
Having inspired by these excellent results, in present study, an attempt was made to investigate the physicochemical properties of BEP and MIP that were exposed to the said Bio-field. The bio-field treated powders were thoroughly characterized by FT-IR, XRD, DSC, TGA, CHNSO, and particle size analysis.
Materials and methods
The BEP and MIP were procured from HiMedia Laboratories Pvt Ltd, India. The samples were grouped into two parts; one was kept as a control sample, while the remaining part was subjected to Mr. Trivedi’s bio-field treatment and coded as treated sample. After that, all the samples (control and treated) were characterized with respect to FT-IR, CHNSO, XRD, particle size analysis, surface area analysis, DSC, and TGA.
Fourier transforms infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy: The infrared spectra of BEP and MIP were recorded with FT-IR spectrometer (Perkin Elmer, USA). IR spectrum was recorded in the range of 4000 to 500 cm-1.
CHNSO analysis: The BEP and MIP were analyzed for their elemental composition (C,H,N,S, and O). The powdered samples were subjected to CHNSO Analyzer using Model Flash EA 1112 Series, Thermo Finnigan Italy.
X-ray diffraction (XRD) study: XRD of BEP and MIP were analyzed using Phillips Holland PW 1710 X-ray diffractometer system. The wavelength of the radiation was 1.54056 angstrom. The data was obtained in the form of 2θ versus intensity (a.u) chart. The obtained data was used for calculation of crystallite size using the following formula.
Crystallite size= kλ/b Cos θ
Where, λ is the wavelength and k is the equipment constant (0.94).
Particle size analysis: The average particle size and particle size distribution were analyzed using Sympetac Helos-BF Laser Particle Size Analyzer with a detection range of 0.1 µm to 875µm. Average particle size d50 and size exhibited by 99% (d99) of powder particles were computed from laser diffraction data table. The d50 and d99 value were calculated using following formula.
Percentage change in d50 size=100 × (d50 treated- d50 control)/ d50 control.
Percentage change in d99 size=100 × (d99 treated– d99 control)/ d99 control.
Surface area analysis: The surface area of BEP and MIP were characterized using Surface Area Analyzer, SMART SORB 90 BET (Brunauer-Emmett-Teller), which had a detection range of 0.1-100 m2/g.
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) study: The BEP and MIP were used for DSC study. The samples were analyzed using a Pyris-6 Perkin Elmer DSC on a heating rate of 10ºC/min under oxygen atmosphere.
Thermo gravimetric analysis (TGA): Thermal stability of the BEP and MIP were analyzed using Metller Toledo simultaneous TGA. The samples were heated from room temperature to 400ºC with a heating rate of 5ºC/min under oxygen atmosphere.
Results and Discussion
The FT-IR spectrum of control and bio-field treated samples are illustrated in Figure 1. The IR spectrum of control and BEP showed (Figure 1) prominent vibration bands at 1760 cm-1 (-C=O) and 1151 cm-1 (-C-O) due to presence of triglycerides peak stretching in the sample. Other important peaks were observed at 2895 and 2817 cm-1 which can be attributed to C-H stretching vibration peaks. The spectrum showed peaks at 1635 and 1587 cm-1 attributed to presence of characteristic protein bands such as amide-I and amide -II stretching vibration peaks [28-31]. Another peak was observed at 3078 to 3780.2 cm-1attributed to -OH stretching vibration peak. The treated sample showed considerable change in FT-IR spectrum (Figure 1). We observed that the presence of triglycerides peak of -C=O (1760 cm-1) and C-O (1151 cm-1) was disappeared in the treated BEP. The result showed that the bio-field treatment, probably removed the fatty triglycerides components from the treated BEP. Additionally, it was also observed that the characteristic –OH/-NH stretching vibration peaks were reduced to lower wavenumbers 3064 cm-1,which indicated the formation of strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding in the treated sample [32,33]. These results suggest that bio-field treatment has induced structural changes in the treated sample.
The FT-IR spectrum of control and treated MIP are presented in Figure 2. The FT-IR of control powder showed (Figure 2) important peaks at 1689 and 1589 cm-1 due to amide-I and amide-II stretching vibration peaks, respectively. Other important peaks were observed at 1760 and 1157 cm-1 for C=O and C-O group, respectively due to triglycerides. However, these two peaks were completely disappeared in treated MIP (Figure 2) which indicated that bio-field treatment affected chemical changes in the treated sample.
Table 1 shows the results of CHNSO analysis of BEP and MIP. The treated BEP showed substantial changes in terms of elemental composition of the treated sample. The treated BEP showed 5.05% increase in nitrogen as compared to control. The oxygen percentage was increased by 3.82% in the treated BEP as compared to control. The carbon percentage was also improved by 2.09% as compared to control sample. Moreover, the treated BEP showed the presence of sulphur element; however no trace of sulphur was found in control sample. The presence of sulphur might play a crucial role in preserving the comminuted meat products . This data showed that the bio-field treatment led to change the elemental composition in BEP.
Whereas the treated MIP showed small percentage change in nitrogen (0.77%) as compared to control powder. However, carbon and hydrogen percentage was decreased by 1.22% and 7.13%, respectively in the treated sample as compared to control. It was observed that there was a significant change in oxygen percentage in treated MIP (24.48%) as compared to control sample. The treated MIP showed some trace of sulphur (0.27%) though no sulphur was found in control sample. All together, the CHNSO results confirmed that bio-field treatment significantly changed the elemental percentage in treated samples.
X-ray diffraction studies
The XRD diffractogram of control and treated BEP sample are illustrated in Figure 3, where, a and b represented to control and treated sample respectively. The XRD showed the amorphous nature of the control sample (Figure 3a) with a broad halo at 2θ equals to 20.0°. The XRD of treated BEP did not reveal (Figure 3b) any differences in X-ray pattern of the sample. The treated samples also showed the broad amorphous nature which was probably due to less ordered atomic arrangement in the sample. The X-ray diffractogram of control and treated MIP are presented in Figures 4a and 4b. The Figure 4a showed a broad amorphous peak at 2θ equals to 22° and Figure 4b showed similar XRD pattern with no change in peak position. Amorphous materials due to random or irregular arrangement in atoms show broad and diffused peaks .
Particle size and surface area analysis
The particle size analysis was carried out on BEP and MIP. The percentage of average particle size (d50) and (d99) were computed and results are presented in Figure 5. The control BEP showed d50 value 11.75 μm and d99 value of 85.39 μm respectively. After treatment d50 value was increased to 12.42 μm and d99 value was increased to 99.1 μm. The percentage change in d50 value and d99 value of the treated BEP was increased by 5.7% and 16.1%, respectively as compared to control sample (Figure 5). This showed that bio-field treatment led to an increase in particle size of the treated samples. It is postulated that the agglomeration of treated BEP may be due to bio-field treatment which causes joining of particle boundaries and hence increase in particle size.
Contrarily, in case of MIP the d50 and d99 values were decreased by 0.4% and 18.1% (Figure 6). Here we assume that the treated powder particles received high bio-field energy which led to deformation of the particle boundaries, and hence it caused a reduction in particle size.
The surface area was analyzed by BET analysis and results are presented in Table 2. The treated BEP showed substantial increase in surface area (1.291 m2/g) as compared to control powder (1.027 m2/g). This was contrary to our particle size results. The surface area of treated MIP (0.625 m2/g) was also increased as compared to control powder (0.488 m2/g). The percentage changes in surface area of the samples (BEP and MIP) were 25.7% and 28% respectively. This was probably due to the fact that, the decreased particle size in MIP caused an increase in surface area. The surface area and particle size changes are usually opposite to each other i.e.,smaller the particles size, larger the surface area and vice versa [36-38]. Hence the more surface area could have been exposed to solvents thereby causing increased solubility.
Differential scanning calorimetry study
DSC is an excellent technique to investigate the glass transition, melting temperature and change in heat capacity of different materials. DSC thermogram of control and treated BEP are presented in Figures 7a and 7b, respectively. The DSC thermogram of control sample (Figure 7a) showed a broad endothermic inflexion at 124.61°C, which was due to melting temperature of the control sample. However, the treated BEP sample showed an elevation in melting temperature as compared to control. DSC thermogram of treated powder showed (Figure 7b) a broad endothermic peak at 192°C. This sharp increase in melting temperature was probably due to the higher absorption of biofield in the treated sample. Hence, the treated BEP need more external thermal energy in order to melt the sample which increased its melting temperature as compared to control.
The DSC thermo gram of both control and treated MIP are presented in Figures 8a and 8b. The DSC thermogram of control MIP showed (Figure 8a) a sharp endothermic inflexion at 131.67°C, which was responsible for its melting temperature. Contrarily, the bio-field treated sample showed (Figure 8b) a broad endothermic inflexion at 182°C which was due to melting temperature of the sample. This confirmed that bio- field treatment enhanced the melting temperature of the treated MIP. This was probably due to increased internal energy that was caused due to Bio-field, which subsequently needed more external energy in order to disturb the material chains.
The increased melting temperature could be correlated to higher thermal stability of the treated BEP and MIP. It can be hypothesized that bio-field has acted as a crosslinker for the collagen present in meat products (BEP and MIP) which probably restricted the molecular mobility that resulted in enhanced thermal denaturation and stability [39,40] Moreover, the specific heat capacity of the control and treated samples were computed from DSC data and results are presented in Table 3. The specific heat capacity was found to be decreased proportionally in both the samples (83.92% and 3.84%). It was assumed that the treated samples (BEP and MIP) were present in corresponding high energy state.
TGA thermo gram of control and treated BEP are illustrated in Figures 9a and 9b. The thermograms of control powder showed (Figure 9a) one step thermal degradation pattern. The control sample started to degrade at 188°C and degradation was terminated at 235°C. Derivative thermogravimetry (DTG) thermogram of the control powder showed the maximum thermal decomposition temperature at 206°C. Similarly, the treated BEP also displayed (Figure 9b) one step thermal degradation pattern. The treated sample started to decompose at 180°C and decomposition step was terminated at 250°C. However, significant increase in maximum thermal decomposition temperature (218°C) was observed in the treated sample, which could be correlated with its higher thermal stability.
Figures 10a and 10b shows the TGA thermogram of control and bio-field treated MIP. TGA thermogram of control MIP showed (Figure 10a) single step decomposition pattern. The sample started to degrade at 165°C and decomposition was stopped at 250°C. The sample showed maximum thermal decomposition temperature at 209°C contrarily the treated MIP showed (Figure 10b) no DTG peak for maximum thermal decomposition temperature. Based on These results, we assume that the bio-field treatment has induced significant thermal changes in both BEP and MIP. The TGA results were also well supported by the DSC data.
The FT-IR data showed a complete disappearance of triglyceride (C=O and C-O) peak in the treated BEP and MIP as compared to control sample. It was shown previously that elevated level of triglycerides could cause serious health concerns such as obesity, hypertension, and high blood glucose levels. More consumption of red meat such as beef could increase the triglyceride level in the humans that further increases health problems. Hence, present work describes that bio-field treatment could be used as possible strategy to remove excess triglycerides. Moreover, it was recently shown that reduced level of triglyceride might improve the aroma and quality of cooked meat. Hence, we assume that bio-field treatment could improve the health and quality of beef and meat products.
This research study was an attempt to improve the physicochemical properties of BEP and MIP using bio-field treatment. FT-IR data showed that bio-field treatment has changed characteristics of treated powders at the structural level. DSC study corroborated increase in melting temperature in BEP and MIP of treated powders as compared to control. However, decrease in specific heat capacity (ΔH) was observed in treated samples (BEP and MIP) as compared to control. It is postulated that no extra energy or heat was required in order to raise the powder temperature as the treated samples were already in high energy state due to bio-field treatment. The increased melting temperature and maximum thermal decomposition temperature of treated samples showed the higher thermal stability. Based on the results achieved, we conclude that, the removal of triglycerides could lead to an improvement in the aroma and food quality of beef extract and meat infusion powder.
The authors would like to thank all the laboratory staff of MGV Pharmacy College, Nashik for their assistance during the various instrument characterizations. We thank Dr. Cheng Dong of NLSC, institute of physics, and Chinese academy of sciences for permitting us to use Powder X software for analyzing XRD results.
1. Yi G, Grabe AV, Bjelanovic M, Slinde E, Olsen K, et al. (2015) Lipid oxidation in minced beef meat with added Krebs cycle substrates to stabilise colour. Food Chem 187: 563-571.
2. Yi G, Haug A, Nyquist NF, Egelandsdal B (2013) Hydroperoxide formation in different lean meats. Food Chem 141: 2656-2665.
3. Brock WH (1997) Justus von Liebig: the chemical gatekeeper. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
4. Gadekar YP, Sharma BD, Shinde AK, Mendiratta SK (2015) Restructured meat products – production, processing and marketing: a review. Indian J Small Rumin 21: 1-12.
5. Van Oostrom AJ, Real JT, Carmena R, Ascaso JF, Castro Cabezas M (2004) Daylong triglyceridaemia in healthy Mediterranean and northern European subjects. Neth J Med 62: 279-285.
6. Kamihiro S, Stergiadis S, Leifert C, Eyre MD, Butler G (2015) Meat quality and health implications of organic and conventional beef production. Meat Sci 100: 306-318.
7. Planck M (1927) Treatise on Thermodynamics, third English edition translated by A. Ogg from the seventh German edition Longmans, Green & Co, London, UK.
8. Einstein A (1905) Does the inertia of a body depend upon its energy-content. Annalen der Physik 18: 639-641.
9. Becker RO, Selden G (1985) The body electric: electromagnetism and the foundation of life, NY, United States.
10. BARNES RB (1963) Thermography of the human body. Science 140: 870-877.
11. Rogalski MS, Palmer SB (2005) Advanced University Physics, (2ndedn), CRC Press, FL, United States.
12. Trivedi MK, Tallapragada RR (2008) A transcendental to changing metal powder characteristics. Met Powder Rep 63: 22-28.
13. Dabhade VV, Tallapragada RR, Trivedi MK (2009) Effect of external energy on atomic, crystalline and powder characteristics of antimony and bismuth powders. Bull Mater Sci 32: 471-479.
14. Trivedi MK, Tallapragada RR (2009) Effect of superconsciousness external energy on atomic, crystalline and powder characteristics of carbon allotrope powders. Mater Res Innov 13: 473-480.
15. Trivedi MK, Patil S, Tallapragada RM (2012) Thought intervention through biofield changing metal powder characteristics experiments on powder characterisation at a PM Plant. Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering-Future Control and Automation. Springer Berlin, Heidelberg.
16. Trivedi MK, Patil S, Tallapragada RM (2013) Effect of biofield treatment on the physical and thermal characteristics of vanadium pentoxide powders. J Mater Sci Eng S11: 001.
17. Trivedi MK, Patil S, Tallapragada RM (2013) Effect of biofield treatment on the physical and thermal characteristics of silicon, tin and lead powders. J Mater Sci Eng 2: 125.
18. Trivedi MK, Patil S, Tallapragada RM (2014) Atomic, crystalline and powder characteristics of treated zirconia and silica powders. J Mater Sci Eng 3: 144.
19. Trivedi MK, Patil S, Tallapragada RMR (2015) Effect of biofield treatment on the physical and thermal characteristics of aluminium powders. J Ind Eng Manag 4: 151.
20. Shinde V, Sances F, Patil S, Spence A (2012) Impact of biofield treatment on growth and yield of lettuce and tomato. Aust J Basic Appl Sci 6: 100-105.
21. Sances F, Flora E, Patil S, Spence A, Shinde V (2013) Impact of biofield treatment on ginseng and organic blueberry yield. Agrivita J Agric Sci 35: 2229.
22. Lenssen AW (2013) Biofield and fungicide seed treatment influences on soybean productivity, seed quality and weed community. Agric J 8: 138-143.
23. Altekar N, Nayak G, (2015) Effect of bio-field treatment on plant growth and adaptation. J Environ Health Sci 1: 1-9.
24. Patil SA, Nayak GB, Barve SS, Tembe RP, Khan RR (2012) Impact of biofield treatment on growth and anatomical characteristics of Pogostemon cablin (Benth). Biotechnology 11: 154-162.
25. Trivedi M, Patil S (2008) Impact of an external energy on Staphylococcus epidermis [ATCC-13518] in relation to antibiotic susceptibility and biochemical reactions -An experimental study. J Accord Integr Med 4: 230-235.
26. Trivedi M, Patil S (2008) Impact of an external energy on Yersinia enterocolitica [ATCC –23715] in relation to antibiotic susceptibility and biochemical reactions: An experimental study. Internet J Alternative Med 6: 2.
27. Trivedi M, Bhardwaj Y, Patil S, Shettigar H, Bulbule A (2009) Impact of an external energy on Enterococcus faecalis [ATCC-51299] in relation to antibiotic susceptibility and biochemical reactions-An experimental study. J Accord Integr Med 5: 119-130.
28. Ellis DI, Broadhurst D, Kell DB, Rowland JJ, Goodacre R (2002) Rapid and quantitative detection of the microbial spoilage of meat by fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and machine learning. Appl Environ Microbiol 68: 28222828.
29. Ammor MS, Argyri A, Nychas GJE (2009) Rapid monitoring of the spoilage of minced beef stored under conventionally and active packaging conditions using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy in tandem with chemometrics. Meat Sci 81: 507-514.
30. Socrates G (2001) Infrared Raman Characteristic Group Frequencies: Tables and Charts. (3rd edition), John Wiley and Sons, West Sussex, UK.
31. Colthup NB, Daly LH, Wiberley SE (1975) Introduction to infrared and raman spectroscopy. (2ndedn), Academic Press, New York.
32. Barth A (2007) Infrared spectroscopy of proteins. Biochim Biophys Acta 1767: 1073-1101.
33. Bender A (1992) Meat and meat products in human nutrition in developing countries. FAO Food Nutr Pap 53: 1-91.
34. Stachurski ZH (2011) On Structure and Properties of Amorphous Materials. Materials 4: 1564-1598.
35. Mennucci B, Martinez JM (2005) How to model solvation of peptides? Insights from a quantum-mechanical and molecular dynamics study of N-methylacetamide. I. Geometries, infrared, and ultraviolet spectra in water. J Phys Chem B 109: 9818-9829.
36. Bendz D, Tuchsen PL, Christensen TH (2007) The dissolution kinetics of major elements in municipal solid waste incineration bottom ash particles. J Contam Hydrol 94: 178-194.
37. Chandler AJ, Eighmy TT, Hartlen J, Hjelmer O, Kosson DS et al. (1997) Municipal solid waste comustor residues: the international ash working group. Studies in Environmental Science, Elsevier science, Amsterdam.
38. Tsereteli GI, Belopol’skaya TV, Mel’nik TN (1997) Thermal properties of the collagen-water system-II. Conformation and conformational mobility of macromolecules in the native and denatured states. Biophysics 42: 575-581.
39. Mu C, Li D, Lin W, Ding Y, Zhang G (2007) Temperature induced denaturation of collagen in acidic solution. Biopolymers 86: 282-287.
40. Su D, Wang C, Cai S, Mu C, Li D, Lin W (2012) Influence of palygorskite on the structure and thermal stability of collagen. Applied Clay Science 63: 41-46.